Business vs Hobby: Navigating the Fine Line with ATO’s Rules

As an accountant, one question I get all the time is, “When does a hobby become a business?” This is a critical distinction when it comes to your tax obligations.

In this post, I’ll walk through the key factors that transform a hobby into a bonafide business in the eyes of the Australian Taxation Office (ATO).

Whether you’re raking in cash from a side gig or have ambitions to launch a startup, you need to assess your activities objectively.

Business vs hobby? Your ATO obligations hang in the balance.

By the end, you’ll confidently classify where you fall on the hobby-to-business spectrum. Let’s jump straight in and shed light on this critical question. The ATO may come knocking one day, so this knowledge will pay off down the track!

Key Differences Between Hobbies and Businesses

When determining whether an activity is a hobby or a business, there are some key characteristics to consider.

Characteristics of a Hobby

A hobby is an activity undertaken for personal enjoyment, relaxation, or leisure. It’s characterised by casual, non-repetitive actions without the intent to make a profit.

Picture an individual crafting bespoke jewellery for their pleasure or as a creative outlet. Occasional sales might occur, but these are incidental and not the primary objective. The ATO views these sporadic transactions as non-commercial, setting hobbies apart from businesses due to the absence of a systematic, profit-driven approach.

Fundamentally, if you’re engaging in an activity for self-satisfaction without an underlying profit motive, it’s categorised as a hobby.

Characteristics of a Business

Conversely, business activities are organised, regular, and unmistakably aimed at generating profit. This could manifest as a local artisan consistently selling their crafts online or at markets.

The ATO recognises a business by its intent for income, evidenced by repeated transactions, structured marketing, and financial planning. Profits might be modest, or the business may not yet be fully sustainable, but the pursuit of profit is unmistakable.

Take, for example, the modern-day social media influencer. If they’re regularly receiving products to market and promote, this activity could be construed as a business. The ATO would examine the regularity and intent behind these transactions.

Are they isolated instances, or is there a discernible pattern that suggests a business operation?

Intent and Profit: Distinguishing a Hobby from a Business

Imagine this: you’re an influencer, and your Instagram started as a canvas for your creativity. But then, brands start sending you products, and suddenly, you’re not just sharing your passion—you’re marketing. With every post that promotes a product, you’re stepping closer to what the ATO defines as a business. It’s not the sporadic gifts that define this shift but the regularity and the strategy behind them.

Now, picture a home baker whose weekend pastries become the talk of the town. If they set up a stall and those treats become a weekly highlight for locals, the ATO isn’t just seeing a hobby; they’re seeing a business unfold.

Or consider a tech whiz who codes for fun but then starts selling their software. It’s not the act of selling that flips the switch for the ATO; it’s the intent to create a steady income stream.

It’s these narratives of passion turning into profit, of consistent effort and strategic planning, that the ATO uses to draw a line in the sand.

So, if your venture is more than just an occasional windfall, it’s time to think about the bigger picture and where you stand with the ATO.

Business Plan: The Role of Intent

When your hobby begins to resemble a business, the ATO looks for evidence of business planning. It’s the foresight in your activities that they scrutinise. Are you seeking out business advice, investing in targeted marketing, or laying the foundations for future expansion? These actions reveal a business mindset.

For example:

A hobbyist photographer who starts to invest in advertising their services is signalling a business intent. It’s not just about the sales you’re making today; it’s about the structure and strategy you’re building for tomorrow. If your trajectory includes scaling your hobby into a primary income source, the ATO will likely recognise your venture as a business, complete with the accompanying tax obligations.

Consequences of Misclassification for Businesses

Mistaking your business for a hobby?

That’s a misstep the ATO doesn’t take lightly. The stakes are sky-high, and the consequences? They can hit your wallet hard.

Imagine this: you’ve been enjoying your craft, casually selling here and there. But if the ATO spots a pattern that spells ‘business’, you could be backtracking through a financial minefield of unpaid taxes, interest, and fines that could leave you reeling.

The ATO plays the role of detective, and they’re good at what they do. They’ll come knocking with a presumption that you’re in business, and it’s your job to prove them wrong. Slip up on providing solid evidence, and you’ll find yourself in a tax tangle that’s tough to untie. And if they sniff out any hint of deliberate dodging? Brace yourself for penalties that escalate from harsh to downright draconian.

So, take the hint:

Clarity is your best ally. Don’t wait for the taxman to come calling. Get ahead of the game, define your venture accurately, and sidestep the tax trap. It’s not just about staying in the clear; it’s about playing it smart with the ATO.


As we’ve journeyed through the maze of distinctions between hobbies and businesses, it’s clear that the line can often seem as fine as a potter’s thread. Yet, in the eyes of the ATO, this line is the difference between a leisurely pastime and a taxable venture.

The crux of the matter always comes down to intent, regularity, and the pursuit of profit.

Don’t wait for the knock of an audit to bring clarity to your situation. Consult with an accountant to illuminate your path, ensuring your passion aligns with the ATO’s expectations. Ready to turn your hobby into a business? Reach out for expert advice and make your next move with confidence.
Want to Simplify Your Tax Prep?

Our FREE guide equips you with pro tips and checklists for both personal and business returns. Download now!

About The Author

Scroll to Top